I’ve gotten an Eeepc 1005PE which is a netbook (ie small) computer. I’m very much happy with it so far and am typing this up on the system. I’ve decided to compare it with the iPad which is also recently released.
Price was $469. The iPad is $629-$1049 depending on HD space and if you want 3G. The Eeepc is far and away cheaper which greatly enhances it’s value.
OS: Windows 7 starter 32bit, iPad uses iPhone OS 3.2. The iPad doesn’t do multitasking and cannot run flash.
Processor: Intel Atom N450 1.66GHz, iPad uses 1GHz Apple A4 chipset which contains an ARM Cortex-A8 CPU
Memory: 1GB DDR2 RAM, iPad has 256MB DDR RAM. This is probably why there is no multitasking yet.
HD: space 250GB, iPad gives a measly 16-64GB
3D capability: Integrated Intel Graphics Media Accelerator 3150. By desktop standards this is very much underpowered. In practice this lets you play lowball 3d games such as Civilization IV. It will not adequately run more demanding games such as Risen. The iPad has 3d capability via the A4 chipset.
Screen: 10.1 inch, 1024×600. iPad has 9.7 inch 1024×768 with a wide viewing angle. The 1024×600 is a rather uncommon standard which can cause issues with things likes games not designed for this standard. The iPad can be viewed from a wider angle which is good for sharing but not good for privacy. Both screens are very crisp and are backlit.
Battery Life: 14 hrs, iPad has 10 hrs still respectable but not as good. Batteries are heavy, the Eeepc has obviously gone for more time rather than less weight.
Wireless connections: 802.11b/g WiFi, No 3G, bluetooth. iPad has 802.11n WiFi, 3G optional for a price, bluetooth.
Touch: only standard laptop style touch mouse. As everyone knows the iPad has a full touch screen which is much better. I use a Logitech M305 cordless mouse with the Eeepc which uses 1 USB port with a truly tiny signal receiver and adds the mouse. This, frankly, is a portability issue. So I must choose the ease of a mouse or the portability of the touchscreen. The iPad is obviously strong here with the only exception being it means fingermark smears on your crisp display.
Keyboard: yes, it’s big enough and easy to use. The iPad uses the touch screen to emulate a keyboard which is so-so in landscape and poor in portrait and of course chews up screen space.
Webcam: Yes a decent 0.3M pixel one is built in. The iPad does not have a webcam.
Sound: Stereo and microphone built in. iPad has mono and microphone built in. Many would use headphones of some kind via bluetooth or the jacks.
Connections: power, VGA video out, 3xUSB, ethernet, SD card, microphone and audio jack. The iPad has an audio jack and a dock connector. The Eeepc is much better here.
Form and weight: The Eeepc is 1.27kg compared to the iPad’s 0.68-0.73kg making the iPad roughly half the weight which is quite a lot less. The iPad also looks sleeker and is not as thick as the Eeepc.
I should note here in case you’re not aware that although the Eeepc, other netbooks and the iPad compete with each other in the same, as I call it, “home or office-roam” market, they have a significant difference in focus. Netbooks such as the Eeepc are offering a full blown computing experience with full application flexibility and fully accessible and flexible filesystem. In other words a miniaturised desktop. It’s designed for you to do with it as you wish. The iPad does not do this, it is instead a very large iPhone without the mobile phone. It’s focus is presentation and the responsive touch interface/OS. This makes it more an entertainment unit. It’s also built around sales through it’s built in and largely mandatory stores. This greatly decays it’s value beyond the price issue.
Obviously I’ve already decided the Eeepc is the superior choice but the iPad still has something to offer.
Continue reading
1005 PE, A4 chipset, Apple, ASUS, comparison, eeepc, iPad, netbook